Weaknesses: not at all waterproof and the liner pulls out of the glove every time you take them off. Have to struggle like Basil Fawlty for 10 minutes putting them back on!
Strengths: Water resistance is good, supple and WARM.
Weaknesses: No padding on palm. Liner feels bit fragile and overall durability?
Overall: I have Raynauds which means I get seriously cold hands most of the year. These have so far performed well as a walking and cycling glove. The liner does not come out on mine although it feels a bit thin and may tear perhaps. They really warm up quickly considering the fairly low bulk. The cut is good too, nice and supple enough after a few weeks use.
I refuse to believe that any glove is ever waterproof for long, and they get damp with sweat anyway but these perform a lot better than some I've used.