Thursday 21 August 2008 | Personalise | Help  
Join today
Join RoadCyclingUK now
Join today
why join?  
Members Logon
Email:
Password:
forgot your
password?
Gatorade top tips
Latest Reviews
6645 Total Reviews
Forum Hot Threads
105216 Total Messages
img_2984.jpg
by Nick Franzini

DT Swiss RWS Q/R skewers tested



DT Swiss RWS titanium quick-release skewer £39.99 each (steel £29.99)

The RWS skewer system from DT Swiss is designed to do away with the cam-operated quick release that has served cyclists so well for over three quarters of a century. About time too, you might say; that's a long time for an engineering solution to keep the upper hand.

For sure, the traditional cam- (or, rather, eccentric-) operated quick release lever has been reinvented often enough, and given its invention by Tullio Campagnolo it is ironic that today, of the major manufacturers, only Shimano still offers something that looks like the original, which sites the lever offset to one side of the cap. That said, the mode of operation remains the same in the shape of the 'flip' action of said lever, which has to generate its clamping force via a short throw of some 160deg. This requires a high leverage ratio.

Instead, the RWS skewer lever rotates about the wheel axle; since it can be turned as many times as desired without fouling anything, it is possible to use a lower leverage ratio and, therefore, get greater clamping force for the same pressure on the lever. This is not the first attempt at such a solution, but the problem is obvious; it is hard to predict where the lever will end up as it reaches the desired tightness. DT gets around this with an ingenious mechanism in the cap. Pulling the lever outwards disengages it from the cap so it can be rotated to the desired orientation. When let go, it springs back into the cap and stays nicely put.



The lever is moulded in a high-strength engineering plastic and is shaped with internal struts for rigidity. The cap mechanism is in light alloy and the skewer itself in either steel or titanium. Weight and cost varies accordingly.

In use, the lever does the job of securing the wheel as effectively as might be expected of a respected firm such as DT Swiss. Once tight, the lever is easily moved to the desired position. However, it is not obvious that this is a better way to do the job than the usual flip lever. As the RWS lever approaches the frame or fork, fingers can touch stays or fork legs as it rotates, whereas the flip lever moves through an unimpeded arc. The distance between the underside of the lever and the clamping face of the cap is small, so some rear dropouts with extended walls can prevent the lever seating at the desired angle. In some installations, perhaps where the skewer nut needs loosening to clear the rear derailleur, the extra turn compared to a flip lever needed to slacken the skewer can be irksome.

On the plus side, the RWS system is light, well-made and reliable and, in the right frame, entirely acceptable. However, it's unlikely that the conventional Q/R will disappear anytime soon on the road.

Titanium skewer available in 100mm (36g), 130mm (39g) and 135mm lengths; steel, 100mm, 135mm, 140mm, 145mm.

Verdict

Lightweight alternative to conventional quick release levers


goodLight, high-tech operation and looks

badNot an obvious improvement on regular QR operation

performance 8
value 8
overall 8

  • www.ultimatepursuits.co.uk
  • www.dtswiss.com

  • Bookmark thisPrinter friendly version
    Want to send this article to a friend? Please join here
     

    Discuss this article, 1 of 11 messages, read more:
    Paul Loring 
    Posted: 18/06/08 01:14:59 59

    There is something clearly very wrong in this world when reviewers are telling us that

    • FORTY QUID for skewers is good value for money.
    • That performance is 8 out of 10 when it doesn't actually do the job any better than ordinary skewers, and in fact infers it may not even be as easy!
    • Only works well in 'some' frames!

    No comment about safety feature for the front forks, while still achieving quick fitting! 

    What do these scores mean, as this sounds to me like: Performance '2', value '0', overall 'Crap'!

    Read more...
    Read member reviews:
    Other (355 products)
    Related articles:
    DT Mon Chasseral wheelset First Ride
    Superlight and superbling Swiss wheelset just needs a small tweak...
    Golden nipples - DT Swiss
    As they have recently acquired the British Pace mtb fork brand, Steve Thomas thought he would drop in on DT Swiss to find out what they are all about.

    Support our partners

    Chain Reaction Cycles


    Skyline Events

    Julies Cycles


    The Real Man