Bike reviews
You are looking at: Home : Bike reviews

Brooks Handlebar Tape

Leather cycling accessories reach the handlebars at last


Posted: 24 April 2007
by Richard Hallett


Sheer luxury

Everything you need for that Brooks feel

Embossed Brooks log

Pack includes Brooks bar end plugs

Comfort and style; dynamo hub optional

Brooks Leather Bar Tape £24.99, £29.99 perforated

When venerable British saddle manufacturer Brooks was bought by the Italian Selle Royal concern in 2004, it was making about 30,000 saddles a year and not much else. Today, saddle output has trebled, while the company has gone back to the catalogues of the early 20th century for inspiration, and now manufactures a range of cycling goodies that includes saddlebags and toolkits. Not found in those old catalogues, but very pleasing nonetheless, is leather tape suitable for wrapping around dropped handlebars.

The mundane aspects of such a product are all covered: each length of tape is easily long enough to cover a full-size bar, and there are a couple of spare bits to put around the back of the brake levers. There is an adhesive strip along the back of the tape. Brooks includes lengths of black finishing tape and a pair of black plastic end plugs decorated with the company logo in raised relief. In order to make the required length from a naturally size-limited material, shorter strips of leather are stitched end to end. So neatly is this done that it does not intrude on the finished appearance of the tape on the bar, although perfectionists may want to reposition the tape during application in order to hide the seams on the underside of the bars.

The sides of the tape are neatly feathered, or ‘skived’ in saddlery-speak, so that they lie flush against the next layer. As the tape is overwound, this creates the spiral bulge familiar from synthetic tape, but the effect is somehow more pronounced and aesthetically very pleasing.

Despite feeling firm and somewhat inflexible straight out of the packet, the tape conforms well to the curves of the bars and brake hoods. With care, there is no reason to find a kink building up at any point. End at the top, and the black tape supplied will provide a finishing touch of a sort, but is too stiff to conform properly. Insulating tape is, as ever, a better option. This means starting at the bottom of the bars, which creates a surplus that has to be tucked inside the end. Unlike synthetic foam tape, leather does not compress easily. Small notches cut in the surplus help to reduce the final internal thickness, which can make the difference between getting the plug in easily or breaking its fingers.

The tape is very comfortable to hold, albeit a little tacky on first application. The honey-coloured version tested gets grubby quickly, although it cleans up easily and feels more comfortable after the first wash. When wet it is a little less successful, since it holds water for some time until it dries. This is to be expected. In any case it is more comfortable when wet or dry than cloth tape.

This is not a product likely to excite too many racing cyclists. It is inevitably heavier than the synthetic opposition, and even more so after a soaking. On the other hand, it feels luxurious, with a welcoming tactile sensation that makes the rider want to hold it, which is more than can be said for most tape. Furthermore, it seems to get better with age, responding well to washing and resisting the minor scrapes and nicks that quickly spoil the appearance of foam tape. With a potential life of several years or more, it even makes some sense in cost terms. The limited palette is a little disappointing, since leather can easily be dyed. Something for the future, Brooks?

Verdict

Comfortable, luxurious and surprisingly easy to fit


goodComfort, pleasing to touch and hold, looks good, long-lasting

badLimited colour range

performance 8
value 7
overall 8


  • www.brooksengland.com
  • www.extra.co.uk

  • Previous article Previous article:
    RCUK Bikes Nathan Boschma's Kinesis Racelight RC
    Next article:Next article
    Parlee Z4: First Look

    TwitterStumbleUponFacebookDiggRedditGoogle


    Discuss this story

    Thing is, you can create a saddle with technical features, geometry and so on. There's only so much you can do with bar tape. I haven't felt the material, but have tried many other different brands of Bar Tape with different materials between them. One thing that remains the same, price bracket. £7-£10

    £24.99!? And it looks like Dale Winton's sun tan.

    Also, sponge is a bigger factor than surface feel, I mean, not many people cycle without gloves.
    Posted: 24/04/2007 17:38

    Have you tried it yet? Thought not. I believe I covered the price angle.
    Posted: 24/04/2007 18:26

    Richard, as I pointed out, I have tried lots of different tape from different manufacturers. The Fi'zi:k bar tape and Bontrager Grippy Tape have a similar concept and take a long time to wear out. Yet, they cost £7 each.
    Posted: 24/04/2007 18:47

    So that's a "no" then is it?
    Posted: 24/04/2007 20:49

    Richard would you replace it if you scuffed it up tomorrow? (looking at the price factor I guess)

    Would you put it on your "everyday bike", "the racer" or the "only sometimes machine that is a bit old school"?
    Posted: 24/04/2007 22:14

    If it got scuffed i'd get out the boot polish, to be honest. I'm thinking of putting some on my tourer. It requires taste and discernment if it is to be properly appreciated, hence the comments of young Tranter.
    Posted: 24/04/2007 22:30

    ''If it got scuffed i'd get out the boot polish, to be honest.''

    Richard, you really are an idiot arnt you. We are talking about bar tape not army boots, I am guessing you will want to buff up your bar tape? Infact no, go ahead and polish your bar tape with boot polish, I hope you get black hands after you have riden and a few people laugh at you. And we ARE talking about bar tape here, not designer clothes, you never thought a company might raise the price over value a little bit?
    Posted: 24/04/2007 23:20

    Going back to Adam's point about 'sponge being a bigger factor than surface feel' - how would it fit over Marsas tape? Is there enough length, flexibility etc?
    Posted: 25/04/2007 07:26

    If it got scuffed i'd get out the boot polish, to be honest. I'm thinking of putting some on my tourer. It requires taste and discernment if it is to be properly appreciated, hence the comments of young Tranter.

    Hold it, is this a lifestyle or bar tape we are trying to sell here?
    Posted: 25/04/2007 08:30

    Think its for sad roadies that dont believe in modern technology.Bet you its heavy.And when BBB do tape for 6 quid it is a touch dear!.
    Posted: 25/04/2007 08:33

    Hang on.

    It's a product review, not a directive to buy from the govenrment.

    I read product reviews on 2000quid wheelsets that I would never buy, Flash bikes that I think are ugly, Rapha tops that belong well and truly back in the 30s/40s/50s (lycra was invented for a reason) etc etc.

    I can appreciate that some people like it, some people will buy it, some people will hate it, some people will think it's overpriced (see the Rapha Jacket thread for that one) and some people won't care.

    Just like Sora and Dura Ace aren't in the same market for 1000 reasons other than price, I would say that this tape and your 5quid vinyl stuff are in totally different markets too.

    If you had a classic/vinatge bike this would be the trick for it. If you have a modern road bike it wouldn't (in my opinion).



    Posted: 25/04/2007 08:52

    Ok oz see your point.
    60cm bike is way too big (my opinion)for you the trek is very un gainly in that size unless your a girraffe!
    I guess on an old vincent it would be good.
    sorry.I just feel 25 quid for tape is steep even by brooks standards.
    Posted: 25/04/2007 09:00

    Comes down to what people want from their bike. Someone who buys this bar tape is probably not the same person who will spend £1000 on a carbon fibre deep section wheelset. If you can afford it and you think it makes a difference then go for it. If I had an endless supply of cash I'd try everything that came on the market (within reason)
    Posted: 25/04/2007 09:20

    .I just feel 25 quid for tape is steep even by brooks standards.

    100% with you on that.

    If you wanted leather bar tape, though, I guess that would be what you have to pay. (Why you would want it must be another story.....)
    Posted: 25/04/2007 09:20

    If I had an endless supply of cash I'd try everything that came on the market (within reason)

    Nathan I have some "spam emails" offering perfomance improvement I could forward to you.....
    Posted: 25/04/2007 09:22

    Returning to Richard's potential "value for money 'cos it [may] last years" point - how long to cable outers last? And hence how often do you have to change the tape for reasons other than the tape being scuffed??

    Or can the Brooks tape be taken off and reapplied neatly?
    Posted: 25/04/2007 09:34

    Good point!I tend to pull outers through with light oil and this seems to prolong life of them.Reuseable tape?Well some are some are not,Depends on the quality!.For 25quid you would hope so.
    Posted: 25/04/2007 09:36

    I think you guys are missing teh point here.

    It's the same thing with Rapha.....you can get something that works perfectly adequately for less than half the price, but if you believe in the look, and want the feel of pure quality, then why the hell not?

    Its £25 because its a great big length of leather which is hardly cheap to produce, and also because it will potentially last for years. I get the impression that people ere are saying that Brooks are blatantly profitering on their name. I don't believe thats the case, adn i am sure if you looked at the production costs of other brands tape, you'd be more alarmed at their mark ups.

    Grrrr.

    And I should imagine you can reapply the tape without damaging the tape unlike other brands, as leather is unlikely to tear or snap at the first suggestion or being removed.
    Posted: 25/04/2007 10:33

    But Brooks are fighting an uphill battle as clothing is acceptable as being fashionable and you can have designer and expensive clothing.


    Posted: 25/04/2007 11:47


    kps
    tut tut some of these responses are shocking. Your acting like a bunch of non cyclists when you tell them the price of a wheel/bike/tyre.....Personally I think it looks great and for the price of a takeaway would set of any tourer. A lovely stove enamelled mercian with b17 and some tape, chrome bars and a nice campag groupo, ah bliss.
    Posted: 25/04/2007 11:57

    lol.
    Can't believe Christian L- S told the Editor he really is 'an idiot, arnt you'.
    The boot polish quip was exactly that- a quip. A jokey one-liner.
    I personally feel the article was fine.
    It's a niche product. Richard Hallett did not advise Brooks on the price, and neither does he have any connection with the brand (that I'm aware of).
    If you don't like the price, don't buy it. Complain to Brooks- they can change it, not Richard!
    Posted: 25/04/2007 12:55

    Well said Tom. If I remember correctly Richard did say in his article that the product would probably not appeal to racing cyclists. I don't see how this bar tape is any different to someone wanting a carbon bottle cage or an alloy one. It's just personal preference. If I had a tourer or old school frame that I had restored I think it would do the bike justice.

    Oz Matt - no need for the emails - lol. As I said "within reason", however doesn't get used anymore at the moment :-)
    Posted: 25/04/2007 13:12

    'This is not a product likely to excite too many racing cyclists'

    and

    with reference to the whingers complaining about the cost...
    'With a potential life of several years or more, it even makes some sense in cost terms'.

    Posted: 25/04/2007 13:15

    ''Can't believe Christian L- S told the Editor he really is 'an idiot, arnt you'.
    The boot polish quip was exactly that- a quip. A jokey one-liner.''

    Well if it was just a joke than I'm sorry but even if you were the queen, anybody putting boot polish on bar tape is an idiot.
    Posted: 25/04/2007 17:17

    of course it's a joke!
    How could it not be?!
    Posted: 25/04/2007 21:36

    It's a product aimed at a niche market - nice, but I wouldn't buy it myself, -- calm down Christian - it's only bar tape!
    Posted: 25/04/2007 23:43

    Well, this thread is a classic already. I'm not even sure whether it was simply the price, (high for sure) or the concept of leather bar tape itself that has annoyed some correspondents.
    Posted: 26/04/2007 16:29

    i think you need to give this stuff a chance... think about it: a leather product is going to have a much greater lifespan than sponge and cork.. some may say it wears in where cork wears out... yes it is 27 pounds but my guess is the leather its easily reusable as it wont rip everytime you retape... i pay 8 pounds everytime i retape with the fizik stuff and at a guess it will outlast 3 tapes of that. aesthetically it wouldnt suit my race bike but i would definatley slap it on a reconditioned steel bike... leather saddle and tape would look very cool on a nice fixed bike... maybe paul smiths mercian if i was loaded... not all road bikes are about climbing weight and stiff bottom brackets... there is always room for everyone to appricate city rolling on something with a bit of sophistication and class... (provided its kitted out in vintage dura ace)
    Posted: 26/04/2007 17:13

    How often do you see the "Brooks Market" rolling around in sophistication and class?

    How often do you see a guy with a terrible beard on a 20 year old Dawes Galaxy (Downtube shifter special)?

    Seriously, it must be a terrible market to sell to as a component manufacturer, the only market and bikes the tape could possibly look half-decent on is the market where no-one ever spends any money!
    Posted: 26/04/2007 19:11


    kps
    "Seriously, it must be a terrible market to sell to as a component manufacturer, the only market and bikes the tape could possibly look half-decent on is the market where no-one ever spends any money!"


    Or the market that spends more money than any other!!

    Have a look round the north american handmade bike show, mucho $$$$$$$$$$$$$ with a good showing of brooks stuff.
    Posted: 26/04/2007 20:03

    Look, it's quite simple, if you think it's overpriced don't buy it.
    Posted: 26/04/2007 20:33

    The Bike Show KPS was talking about.

    What "some of us" need to realise is that just because we don't like something, it doesn't mean it is crap.
    Posted: 26/04/2007 20:57

    It's nice to see that Brooks are still in the game, these products are bought by a small segment of cyclists who are looking for something different from the majority, those who chose to restore old bikes, and cherish them as do vintage car enthusiasts, - or otherwise, silly to diss them, for not being part of the mainstream, people own bicycles for many different reasons, you make too many assumptions Adam, the retro bike market is very strong in the UK as well as the US, can that be a bad thing? no.
    Posted: 26/04/2007 22:17

    Adam - why don't you conduct and experiment and get some Brooks Bartape in stck see how it sells over the next few weeks then report back to us. Will show how the market is for this sort of thing in your location.You never know - it may just run out the door.
    Posted: 26/04/2007 22:20

    Yet another heated debate based on percieved value for money, stereotyping potential buyers and criticizing complete strangers for not dropping straight into the "everything carbon + full team kit" mould.

    And nobody's tried it.

    Looks like I'm the only one actually using this tape then!

    Way more durable than cork, better grip and sweat absorbtion than Fizik - looks a little strange on my Bianchi S9 but then again so do I.
    And every so often a thin coat of proofide makes it look new. Haven't tried boot polish though. I've rewrapped the bars twice since I got it (new bars & cables) and no problems to report.

    Putting a Brooks saddle and tape on a modern £3k race bike might seem strange but it's all about the comfort. Don't knock it until you've tried it - our sport is hard enough without unnecessary discomfort in the name of fashion.
    Posted: 27/04/2007 00:47


    TCx
    Would you give it a chance Adam if it was black and so blended in with every other tape on the market?

    Posted: 27/04/2007 07:57

    You mean like the black version?
    Posted: 27/04/2007 08:21

    Would you give it a chance Adam if it was black and so blended in with every other tape on the market?

    You may joke, but if it was black it would just be overpriced, and not overpriced and ugly.

    Everyone who spends the money on bar tape is not going to say it's rubbish are they? Otherwise you'd look a bit silly.

    It's the same reason no-one ever says their brand new race bike isn't as good as they'd thought it would be.
    Posted: 27/04/2007 08:33

    Adam - why don't you conduct and experiment and get some Brooks Bartape in stck see how it sells over the next few weeks then report back to us. Will show how the market is for this sort of thing in your location.You never know - it may just run out the door.

    I am tempted. But I can almost guarantee you there is no market for it where we are. People don't want to spend money on bar tape, those that ride in the "Brooks" market (Long moustache, old clothing, clips and straps, I mean, there adverts are just a bit backwards) seriously, don't spend any money. Try and tell someone that £30 bar tape is good value on their Dawes Supergalaxy. The reason they're still riding that, is no-one changes anything besides chains and cassettes on those bikes. I see it every week.
    Posted: 27/04/2007 08:36


    kps
    Adam have you ever owned a Brooks? I wonder if this is all about those that have and those that haven't. After dedicating a 1000 or so miles to break in a Brooks to the shape of your ass you get quite attached to it....literally. Call it stockholm syndrome.:)

    I guessing you won't be turning up at your next race in this then

    http://dashingtweeds.co.uk/dt/?page_id=43
    Posted: 27/04/2007 08:46

    See more comments...
    Talkback: Brooks Handlebar Tape

    First Name:
    Last Name:
    Nickname:
    Email:
    Security Image:
    Enter the code shown:

    I agree to the site's Terms and Conditions & Code of Conduct: